The early Christmas present you’ve all been waiting for: the complete print out and keep guide to Theresa May’s Long & Winding rock n roll Road Show to nowhere.
Theresa May has learned nothing from her General Election débacle. Strong and Stable as a mantra has been replaced by The only deal available that defends British jobs gives us back control of our borders and honours the 2016 Referendum. It’s longer, but none the wiser.
Its other flaw is in being completely false. As a threader here remarked yesterday, “She has negotiated a Withdrawal Agreement which is neither a withdrawal nor an agreement”. That is indeed true. But as ever, she is convinced that if she repeats it enough, people will come to believe in it.
If only I could be nicer about the rentagobs who disagree with her. I watched yesterday morning as Baron Astonish burbled on at Adam Boulton: it was the Baron’s best illustration yet that he is a man in need of mental help. He discussed six separate aspects of the Whadawedonext debate, and concluded for each, “This is the sole reason we are in this mess”. To be able to divide one into six and get one as the answer is as certain a sign as you’ll ever see of madness.
The equally bald but even more gobby bloke standing next to Admonish was not so much mad as muddled. He was, he insisted, a believer in democracy, and thus felt the Second Referendum was the only way to go. Boulton needled him only slightly on this obvious cognitive dissonance before Baldy2 said – in a zero irony response – that “What we need is for the People to decide what sort of Second Referendum they need”.
“You see Minister,” said Sir Humphrey, “the People need to tell themselves what kind of referendum they need by voting about what they want to say next time, prior to reaffirming in a third referendum what they said the first time.”
As the May Commons update approached yesterday, Jeremy Corbyn announced that he would call a non-binding vote of no confidence in Mrs May rather than the Government, but then almost immediately dropped the idea. Even the ghost of Sir Humphrey would struggle with that episode, but let’s see how he manages it, with his usual wry smile:
“Minister, Mr Corbyn is merely signalling that he has confidence in Mrs May’s ability to inadvertently screw the EU which he hates although for tactical reasons must pretend he likes but equally doesn’t want to be handed a crown of thorns with a chalice of poisoned wine by becoming Prime Minister just yet, and so wants to be assured that in the unlikely event of him winning such a vote of no confidence only Mrs May would go, thus leaving the Conservative Party in a pickle clumsily wrapped in fibreglass which he can then condemn at PMQs every Wednesday, however at the last minute John McDonnell told him the idea is to go for a Second Referendum and so, being a man of rigid principle, unstinting consistency – but chiefly inestimable survival wisdom – Her Majesty’s Leader of the Opposition bowed to his advisers”.
Came the hour, came the Daft Mare. Some are born to be leaders, some have leadership thrust upon them, and some steal leadership from others vastly better qualified than they. Mrs May told us that the vote she backed out of on December 11th will now take place – with Commons debates beforehand – on January 14th.
What is likely to happen between then and now, apart from Christmas?
The Prime Minister told the Commons:
“I know this House is still deeply uncomfortable about the backstop. And I understand that. And I want us to go further still in the reassurances we secure. Discussions with my EU partners – including Presidents Tusk, Juncker and others – have shown that further clarification following the Council’s conclusions is in fact possible. So discussions are continuing to explore further political and legal assurances.”
Sir Humphrey intervenes once more:
“Minister, it is important always to remember that a backstop is really nothing more than (if I might put into words what the Prime Minister said) what insurance companies never want to insure against, that is – something which seems very unlikely to happen but always does. It is clear that the Prime Minister believes – while it has been emphatically stated by Brussels that no such possibilities exist – certain plausible but meaningless clarifications might be forthcoming. This could mean, more or less, that a meaningful vote can occur on January 14th about meaningless side letters in such a manner as to reassure persons of a less than discerning nature that continuing explorations of assurances are in fact meaningful and thus likely to bring concrete meaning to hitherto and to fore ethereal considerations.”
I make only one firm and convinced prediction about what will happen in due course: somebody with gumption and a sharp mind will write a script about this saga when it finally comes to some sort of end, and Hollywood will be falling over its knickers to buy the rights*.
I nominate Helen Mirren to play May, John Slattery to play Corbyn, Corbyn to play Sir Humphrey Appleby, Diane Abbott to play silly buggers with the statistics, and Billy Bragg in a cameo role as the inevitable busker singing All Around my Hat outside the railings of Downing Street.
But while we’re waiting for that End Game, whassnext?
—————————————————————-
Several million citizens appear to think that the next major event will be full-on Armageddon….and have begun panic buying. Apart from the likelihood of most of them being Remaindeer, I am at a loss to know why. Whatever the answer, this has hilariously coincided with a decision by Britain’s retailers to slash prices, the hard up British consumer seemingly displaying little interest thus far in the Christmas splurge. So now, websites and shops are heaving with dingbat Remain flappy-bottoms and Leave bargain hunters.
Rather than being a movie in real time, the Parliamentary process is taking on all the features of a third-rate amdram provincial pantomime. Yesterday we had “Oh yes he will/won’t!” shouted by Corbyn Labour, and today his ugly sister across the divide is taunting with “Oh no you daren’t!”, to which the Peter Pan lad isself insists, “Oh yes I do….look behind you!”
But behind She Who Must be Obeyed, the rebels have shot their bolt, and Labour knows it. Corbyn himself admits the motion will fail….and there aren’t anywhere near enough Tories prepared to put Nation before Party and vote with the Opposition. The sad reality is that, behind the Ugly Sister herself, there are 280+ equally wart-riddled Uglies who want to put off the inevitable burning of their backsides.
The Conservative Party wants to have the cake and eat it too – and those with double standards always want double helpings. What we should have is a General Election once the Withdrawal Bill fails again on January 14th. But we won’t.
Yet again however – and this is so typical of May – she has boxed herself into a corner by openly insisting several times on camera that a second referendum would not solve anything, and represent an insult to democracy. In truth, what she fears is that Leave would win another victory, and force her into a “harder” Brexit….something, as a dyed in the wool geopolitical Remainoid, she is anxious to avoid at all costs.
My suspicion is that she will try one or both of two tactics to keep the clock ticking nicely down towards Brexit-Day, by when a Government (not necessarily hers) will ask for cooperation from Labour Remainers to achieve an extension to Article 50.
First, between now and January 6th (ish), Whitehall will look – in concert with their oppos in Brussels – to come up with a form of comfort side-letter suggesting that only a plague of boils would trigger the backstop. This will be leaked to the press in its best light, and declared by both UK, European and US media as the Big Breakthrough for which we’ve all been waiting….and scrape through the Commons on the 14th.
For myself, I don’t think a convincing ‘budge’ by the Eurocrats will be forthcoming – and even if it was, I doubt if it would have a snowball in Hell’s chance of getting a Commons majority without being so mauled, it would then be unacceptable to the Sprouts. (Bear in mind that Dominic Grieve has already clearly established Parliament’s right to add amendments and change content that alters the substance previously negotiated by Überstürmbannfuhrer Robbins in Brussels).
Second, once the Bill fails, May will (I’m sure) give yet another speech about her “unsparing” determination to carry on negotiations, hoping again to keep running down the clock.
I have a sneaking hunch, however, that behind the public facade, the Remain candidates for her job have no desire to get another year of Theresa May. I think there is every possibility that she will face a Remainer Cabinet revolt forcing her to resign (if she resigns, the Tories can have another leadership contest) – and she will give way to another Remainer PM….who will call for an extension to Article 50, get that through Parliament relatively easily, and then….and then….God only knows.
—————————————————————-
Once the ides of March are upon us – and Brexit is looking increasingly remote – probably one or more of two major events will occur.
First, the Blairite breakaway from Corbyn Labour will probably have happened. And second, the Faragist anti-Brexit Party will almost certainly be launched.
There is also a third matter – the political career of Boris Johnson. If he were to join forces with Nigel Farage, there could be serious chance of other Tories following, and a bloc of ‘Independence’ seats created in Parliament if and when another election is called, or by elections occur.
Last but not least, there is the econo-fiscal storm still brewing around the world that might itself be triggered by eurozone crises in one for or another. That crisis is, I still maintain, infinitely more important than anything served up by a bunch of tin-pot dictators in Brussels, Strasbourg and Frankfurt.
For the time being, I recommend taking the kids to a real pantomime and forgetting Brexit entirely until Boxing Day is behind us.
Spot on JW
As for the Hollywood script on BREXIT, why wait for it, write it yourself and you could join John Cleese in St Kitts and Nevis, Nice places and warmer [all the time] then France.
As for Nigel and Boris, shacking up together, only when hell freezes, both are self-centred people, both know it and can’t trust each other.
I think you may be right, May will get her deal through parliament. The party will have a change of leadership, but no one wants an election just yet.
Too much is likely to happen in the next two or three years, better to blame the party in office [I won’t say power]
The get out clause for the back stop [when the time comes] will be a referendum on the unification of the island of Ireland. By then;
Most Irish in NI will have joint citizenship anyway, and the Catholics voters will have out bred the Protestants by then. [a bit like they who can’t be named in the UK?EU by 2050]
So I think JW write your script and move to St Kitts etc ASAP.
LikeLike
My Brain Hurts
LikeLike
Now the date for the vote has been set (again) I suppose that we have got another horrible black swan event to look forward to between now and then – it seems almost inevitable.
LikeLike
“Last but not least, there is the econo-fiscal storm still brewing around the world that might itself be triggered by eurozone crises in one for or another. That crisis is, I still maintain, infinitely more important than anything served up by a bunch of tin-pot dictators in Brussels, Strasbourg and Frankfurt.”
True that. Could be triggered by Chinese debt bubble implosion too – or one of many other things flashing red around the massively-overindebted-at-all-levels-of-society world at the moment.
I’ve got my motorhome, my tins of baked beans and my packets of noodles, plus a water filter. So I’m OK.
Oh – and gold. I’ve been buying more of that. I’d do the same if I were you, and if you don’t, well don’t say you weren’t warned…
LikeLiked by 1 person
The trouble with May’s, and other famous withdrawal methods is that someone inevitably gets fckd….and we end up with things like ‘Lord’ Adonis
LikeLike
I never thought the Ponziopoly scheme would last this long. I’m also saddened that Hasbro hasn’t brought out a themed version by the same name.
The question really is. When the wheels come off it, will they have contrived a little war with Russia and or China to mitigate their crimes?
What we need is a New Pearl Harbour event……..
LikeLike
Wow you have rubbed your crystal ball John and let the genius that is your mind, out of the bottle. I never liked pantos and now I remember why. I always got confused about who was the goodie and who was the baddie so was known to boo at the wrong times. Looking back though, maybe I was right all along. All I know is, afterwards I always had to go for a stiff drink and I was only 12!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The recall of MPs Act of 2015 set very rigid guidelines for getting shot of a worthless MP. Apparently lying though your teeth to constituents is not considered sufficient grounds. Sadly Zac Goldsmith tabled a number of amendments that would have replaced the Government’s system of recall, triggered by a MP’s conduct, with a system that allowed voters to initiate a recall process. The amendment was pressed and was defeated on a division.
We the electorate desperately need a mechanism to bring Mps to heel, to honour the promises that enabled them to be both selected and elected. The electorate should have the power to punish individual MPs that renege, whenever they feel the need, not just at General Elections.
The 2015 Act needs to be revisited and redrafted to look after the constituents, not the individual MP!
LikeLiked by 1 person
JOHN
Meanwhile back in the real world:
Stuff is happening .The Chinese are getting nasty over one of their own . Big noises regarding one of their own getting his/her collar felt.
A bit like the UK in the 30s in my opinion? (The gambling scams wheezes) being used to fund the new comers…………mortgages and set up dosh to start up “legit money spinners”.
Some of the biggest Chinese gambling dens /places are Yanky owned ….still?
Interesting times indeed.
And still our own ………. continue to piss into the wind.
LikeLike
A few bits and bobs worth sharing. Just look at the arrogant candour from Vince Cable in City AM today (18th December):
“I will content myself with describing three “hunches” about what I think may happen – not as brave as predictions.
“First, it is clear that the government is talking up the no-deal melodrama in order to frighten business and the wider public into getting behind the Prime Minister’s deal. But since the government has it entirely within its power to stop a no-deal Brexit (by revoking Article 50), the strategy will not work. I believe that the cabinet will tell Theresa May that she has no alternative – however much she hates it – than to go back to the public for a referendum, because her Brexit deal has a better chance there than in parliament.
“The detail will be set out in parliamentary legislation and the Commons will insist on remain being an option. Even if more radical options are allowed onto the ballot paper, the choice will resolve itself into the one tangible form of Brexit available – her deal – or to remain. Naturally, I favour the latter and am currently looking for the best odds in the market.”
http://www.cityam.com/270696/might-happen-2019-second-referendum-economic-recession-and
Also from City AM, an insight into the presure Corbyn is coming under (they view Corbyn caving in as the quickest route to a second referendum).
‘Under the Fixed Term Parliament Act, should the government lose a vote of no confidence, an election must be put in motion within 14 days, if a new government cannot be formed.
‘Victory for Labour in this circumstance is unlikely – DUP MPs are not going to back an election that could give away the tremendous position of power they find themselves in.
‘The inability to win that vote would mean the Labour leadership having to embrace a position it has tried so hard not to support: another referendum.
‘The party agreed at conference that if a general election could not be forced, securing another public vote on the UK’s EU relationship would be the next ambition. Shadow chancellor John McDonnell believes this move is “inevitable”, but Corbyn is reluctant to push the button which would see it becoming the party’s official position. It seems the government is trying to force Labour into backing such a move, perhaps calculating that it would dent Labour’s support among Brexit-backing members of the public.’
http://www.cityam.com/270702/another-day-unforced-errors-jeremy-corbyn
And finally, just check out this piece of Orwellian nastiness dressed up as do-goodery:
https://www.politico.eu/article/britain-nationalist-dark-web-populism-tommy-robinson/
LikeLiked by 2 people
Exiting times John. Happy Christmas & New Year to you.
As you say IABATA,
LikeLiked by 1 person
I reiterate what I said before: there is a plan behind all these machinations. May and her husband ‘wargamed’ the confidence vote and won (despite those 100 or so who voted against her). Brexit must surely have also been ‘gamed’ and an end game predicted. If you listen to her rhetoric it is all about ‘leaving the Eu on the 29th March 2019’. I think she means it, whether that be her Chequers plan, or a clean Brexit. However, when faced with the Uk leaving without a deal, the unelected EU hierarchy , frightened about the consequences to their comfortable lives, will come up with a ‘last minute’ offer. Watch and wait.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Sic transit gloria Backstop
LikeLike
JW
Wishing you a May Free Christmas And a Happy No Deal….
S
LikeLiked by 3 people
Mucho applauso John, very well delivered. I entirely agree with you, as must be obvious.
As to what happens eventually if the May and the likely Barely Modified May Plan sink the already relentlessly told two choices will remain. Abandon Brexit in the short term at least or Extend and pretend to ultimately abandon Brexit. As May herself has stated, No Brexit is better than Bad Brexit, except she actually said Deal but Brexit is what she meant.
The compliments of the season to one and all.
LikeLike
Your Sir Humphrey is really quite clear, when you think about it
The chances of another Remaindeer Tory PM borders on fantasy
We will have a Brexiteer opposed by an alleged born again Brexiteer who used to be a Remaindeer but is now a two faced lying, not to be trusted psycho but has our best interests in mind at all times.
I really don’t see the Tory party faithful falling for that …again
So its only possible to be between two people – Boris and Dominic Rabb
Whether MPs put Boris forward for the final two is questionable, but he does have one really important thing going for him….Boris wins elections.
merry xmas
LikeLiked by 2 people