REVIEW: A tale of two books

A stinker from Tom Sharpe, and a hoot from Sue Townsend.

As the heat of August tails off down here, I’ve been getting some hammock reading in. While briefly in Wales two weeks back, I went into an excellent independent bookshop and purchased five titles – all of them on my list of must-reads. Had I stayed an hour longer there, I could’ve found another twenty; in W H Smiths these days, I can never find anything worthwhile at all.

The first book I started was a belated novel from the now ageing Tom Sharpe, The Gropes. It seems that after a near-death experience a couple of years ago, Sharpe decided he had one more novel in him. It’s a pity it didn’t stay there.

In his mid 1970s heyday, Sharpe wrote the funniest socio-political farces on the market. Riotous Assembly, Wilt and Blott on the Landscape were all laugh-out-loud books. Then – as suddenly as he had appeared – Tom went quiet. The Gropes is a very sad epilogue to his glittering career.

What can I tell you? The jokes are leaden, the characterisations dated, the writing sloppy, and the plot plain daft. Not funny daft – or even better, surreal satirical daft like they used to be – just daft.

Contrast this disappointment with the ever-fresh series of Adrian Mole books churned out by Sue Townsend. By definition contemporary, they are marvelously observed, ironically mordant statements on pc hypocrisy, and the failed aspirations of so many children of Thatcher who thought themselves Steve Jobs, but turned out to be just more bitter Del Boys.

My own view is that the series gets funnier with every book, and her latest – Adrian Mole: the Prostrate Years – is sheer comic genius from start to finish. It starts with the Brown coronation in 2007 and follows the further disillusionment of Adrian with all the ghastly elements of Cool Britannia become Cruel Britannia. Trust me, you’ll be rationing this book after just a few pages, and giggling on every page. The description of a gay funeral for Graham the Dog is, I fancy, destined to become a classic literary snippet.

3 thoughts on “REVIEW: A tale of two books

  1. I quite agree John. I love Tom Sharpe's books and actually re-read the lot this summer except the final "Granschester Grind" book. That's when he lost his edge; writing a sequel for the BBC. He said at the time he hated writing to order doing in fact something Wilt would have hated. His writing never recovered and he should have left the last book unpublished to be discovered 10 years after his death


  2. I agree, loved all the early Tom Sharpe books but "Granschester Grind" seemed to have been written by someone else and he lost me as a reader. Love Pratchett but he has gone the same way, probably for a very good reason but someone is taking the mick…………


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s